On Daryl Hall and the Marxist Dialectic

I got a B- in Marxism in college. In fact, I’m pretty sure I pulled an all-nighter with the Cliffs Notes Communist Manifesto to pass the final exam, so I’m not sure if what I’m remembering as the Marxist dialectic is actually the Marxist dialectic, but I did learn one very important thing in Marxism 101: There is no such thing as objective truth. Marx believed that truth is relative depending on one’s material circumstances. The notion that Truth with a capital T did not exist blew my mind at age 21 and has stayed with me though the years, helping me sort out the world, though I don’t think money is the only thing that defines one’s reality.

…which brings me to the topic of last night’s Daryl Hall concert at the Mahaiwe Performing Arts Center in Great Barrington. I was never a huge Hall and Oates fan, though of course the lyrics to their many 80s neo-soul hits (Rich Girl, Kiss on My List, Sara Smile, and She’s Gone, to name but a few — the duo sold more than 60 million albums) are engraved onto my generation’s DNA.

I looooved the concert and while nostalgia was part of my response, it wasn’t the dominant element. Daryl sang a lot of his hits, but with looser, more ragged and free wheeling arrangements than the originals. The band of veteran musicians rocked. Daryl held court in what I perceived to be a relaxed, dignified, generous, soulful, and utterly seductive and charismatic manner. The upper registers of his voice aren’t what they once were, but he sang the hell out of the songs, delivering them as himself in the present, not as a washed up pop star clinging to his former glory. And he looked darn good. Whatever vitamins he’s taking: they’re working.

I gather that lately he’s been broadcasting concerts from his house in nearby Dutchess County. The Mahaiwe performance felt similarly intimate and done just for the fun of it. Daryl doesn’t need to prove anything to anyone. I had the sense that he was performing because he loves music. There’s no better gift for an audience.

Soooo…I was surprised by my friend Seth’s review of the concert this morning. It’s like he saw a different show. Marx helps me understand how that was possible.

7 Responses to On Daryl Hall and the Marxist Dialectic

  1. Dan Shaw says:

    Maybe the answer is not in Marxism but in sexism? I doubt that Seth ever found Hall sexy or attractive when he was a teen, and certainly not now.

  2. Gina Hyams says:

    I’m not here to judge anyone’s reality other than my own. But, yes, I do believe my assessment of Daryl’s appeal is more objective than Seth’s from a straight woman’s perspective.

  3. Countess Bedelia says:

    Hi Gina, I stole your Power of Ten meme for my blog.

    Thanks from a new reader and a great fan of BTF…

    The Countess

  4. rebecca says:

    Also I hate to challenge Mr. R but I don’t believe there was ever an MTV vid of Sara Smile.

  5. Gina Hyams says:

    Countess! You are LEGEND. Thanks so much for stopping by my blog and I’m honored that you did the meme.

    I’ve been thinking more about Dan’s comment and I don’t think sexism, or even gender, has much to do with the differing opinions. I think it’s just human to experience the world from different perspectives.

    I deal with a lot of critics in my job and sometimes when the theater gets a bad review, people assume I must get angry about it, which is rarely the case. I get annoyed when critics get their facts wrong (mixing up names or phone numbers), but opinions are opinions and it’s the job of critics to call things as they see them. I don’t have to 100% agree with people to like or respect them.

  6. Beverly Kaye Gallery says:

    Loved your blog. Saw and was mesmerized by Sweet Baby James in concert in the Berkshires……oh how we are tied to the old songs! BTW my kids are expecting twins next week so your book about Nannies is high on the to buy list. Just in time!

  7. Gina Hyams says:

    Thank you, Beverly…and your outsider art gallery looks very interesting.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Instagram
Copyright © Gina Hyams